C50 vs Sportster 883 - Page 3 - Motorcycle-Journal Forums

Rickster · 11-09-2007, 11:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TFee3

I'm not sure how much increase your budget can stand, but I might suggest that you go to a C90T if you're going to ride 2-up. I went in to pick up a C50T, but talked the dealer into selling me the C90T for the discounted price he quoted me a month before. My friend paid $10,000 more for his Softtail Classic and then had to add almost $2,000 more for saddle bags and windshield. I have nothing against Harleys except for the price. I couldn't see paying another $10,000 for something with less equipment and 15 less hp. Doesn't make sense to me.

Wow, for a guy that doesn't have anything against Harley's, you sure do like to put down the one your buddy bought. That's the third time you've told that same lame story. I call it lame, because all you do is generalize, how about some particulars on the $2000 he had to spend, and what all this extra equipment is that your bike came stock with.

TFee3 · 11-09-2007, 06:33 PM

Hey clown (Rickster), read the post I just posted in your other putdown of my comments, and you'll know. Again, pull your head back in the sunshine!

Rickster · 11-09-2007, 10:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TFee3

Hey clown (Rickster), read the post I just posted in your other putdown of my comments, and you'll know. Again, pull your head back in the sunshine!

Read the rules. Name calling is not allowed on here. Than go and read my reply to your other post, you will see that my head is clearly in the sunshine.

dcstrng · 11-10-2007, 12:19 PM

<his Softtail Classic and then had to add almost $2,000 more for saddle bags and windshield...>

Uh, the Classic (FLSTC) comes with bags and windshield...

Hmmmm....

m50cruiser · 01-01-2008, 09:47 PM

I Agree With Hammersfan, Just Get An M50 And All Ur Troubles Will Disapear.
Keep The Shiny Side Up
M50 Cruiser

Nick Mystic · 01-01-2008, 11:04 PM

Back in August when I was researching bikes before I made my purchase I ran across a great article at the Motorcycle.com web site. It was a comparison of four of the most popular light middle weight cruisers including, the Suzuki M50, the HD 883, the Kawasaki Vulcan 900, and the Honda Shadow 750 Aero. Four reviewers rated all four bikes and all four agreed that the Suzuki M50 was their choice as the best bike.

Here is the link: 2006 Light-Middleweight Cruiser Comparison

I ended up buying a 2007 M50 Limited Edition and have been extremely pleased with it. Good luck with your decision making.

omegajim · 01-02-2008, 01:32 PM

How close behind was the Kawasaki 900 Vulcan?

I kind of like the looks of the Kawasaki, and besides the rest of the crowd can by the M50/C50

I remember once that I drove along with a guy who had a HD 883 and I was on the old Yamaha 850. Usually, from the stop sign, I would pull ahead and have to slow down to let him catch up.

After we got to our destination the HD guy said "What are you driving so fast for, I had trouble keeping up."

I replied "Fast, heck that was a bit over half throttle, you ain't seen fast yet."

Although I've heard the HD Sportster 1200 is supposed to be pretty zippy.

Ext1jdh · 01-02-2008, 02:45 PM

If you want to compare the Sportster 883 to any Suzuki cruiser, you have to compare it to the S50. Theres just no other way.

POE-BOY SAMICH · 01-02-2008, 03:15 PM

Not a big fan of the 883. The only one I've ever ridden was a VERY rough ride.
Granted I only rode it for about 10miles and I have no other experience with the 883 sportsters. The one I rode was the 883L (low).

I do love the look of the nightster though.
That's a sweet looking ride.

Having owned a C50, if I was gonna get a bike and I could only choose between a C50 or a Sportster 883 (the 2 bikes mentioned in the original post) I would go with the C50 in a heartbeat. There really is no comparison IMO.

DANG! This is an old thread though, no?

Rickster · 01-02-2008, 03:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by POE-BOY SAMICH

Not a big fan of the 883. The only one I've ever ridden was a VERY rough ride.
Granted I only rode it for about 10miles and I have no other experience with the 883 sportsters. The one I rode was the 883L (low).

I do love the look of the nightster though.
That's a sweet looking ride.

Having owned a C50, if I was gonna get a bike and I could only choose between a C50 or a Sportster 883 (the 2 bikes mentioned in the original post) I would go with the C50 in a heartbeat. There really is no comparison IMO.

DANG! This is an old thread though, no?

chance3290 · 01-02-2008, 03:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ext1jdh

If you want to compare the Sportster 883 to any Suzuki cruiser, you have to compare it to the S50. Theres just no other way.

Yeah, that's what I was thinking too. HP and equipment-wise, the S50 is much closer to the 883. They're both really hot at that red-light, in the summer.

Scott58 · 01-05-2008, 10:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chance3290

Yeah, that's what I was thinking too. HP and equipment-wise, the S50 is much closer to the 883. They're both really hot at that red-light, in the summer.

On paper that might appear to be true, but in reality the S50 is a closer match to the 1200cc HD. My brother-in-law has the 1200 and I have the S50. Both 05's, both are bone stock. He has more comfort, but that's where it ends. The S50 can out maneuver and out brake the HD. That alone would sway my purchase, but even performance wise he has yet to beat me in high speed roll ons and short speed contests, but it's so close he could easily even the odds just going on a diet. He also paid twice what I did. If you want a harley get one, but don't confuse them with value. The real choice here is "bang for the buck" or american icon?

omegajim · 01-05-2008, 09:57 PM

Lots go for the american icon thing.

If i had money to throw away, i'd buy an icon too.

Right after I win the lottery.

sgt_murf · 01-21-2008, 12:39 AM

Not saying I have the answers as this one's personal choice. When I was younger the first road bike I learned to ride was a 59 pan, rode several sporty's 883, 900, 1200's, Road Kings, FL's FLH's. Today I have a C50T why? It's comfortable, handles well, do I miss the Harley's yes to a degree, which one is better -- depends on your view of better, pick what you like ride it and enjoy it. All bikes have their strong and weak points the only bikes I never like was the one's produced in the Soviet regime I thought they was crude. But I know some whom likes them, again indivdual choice. What's important is that you are in the wind and enjoying it.

dcstrng · 01-24-2008, 12:09 PM

<pick what you like ride it and enjoy it…>

I think that is the correct answer… if raw performance was the issue, looking at anything cruiser-esque is silly… if availability of parts is an issue, looking at almost any bike except a big-twin HD is equally silly… if pure comfort is the answer, the touring bikes own the landscape… fact is, once one has ridden a few scoots over many years, I think one becomes far less parochial and just begins to enjoy the ride… except for those who envision a garage-queen, actually riding becomes proportionally more essential than just what one is straddling…

skynyrd fan · 01-27-2008, 12:07 PM

After God , my wife and family, I love my C50. Looks like a no brainer from what Im reading here.

skynyrd fan · 01-27-2008, 12:08 PM

Let us know how you make out.

11-10-2007, 12:19 PM	#44 (permalink)
dcstrng Ditch Magnet Join Date: Jun 2006 Bike: `96 FLHT Location: Colonial Beach, VA Posts: 183	<his Softtail Classic and then had to add almost $2,000 more for saddle bags and windshield...> Uh, the Classic (FLSTC) comes with bags and windshield... Hmmmm.... __________________ Larry -- IBA

01-01-2008, 11:04 PM	#46 (permalink)
Nick Mystic In Training Join Date: Sep 2007 Bike: Suzuki M50 Limited Edition 2007 Location: Western North Carolina Posts: 146	Back in August when I was researching bikes before I made my purchase I ran across a great article at the Motorcycle.com web site. It was a comparison of four of the most popular light middle weight cruisers including, the Suzuki M50, the HD 883, the Kawasaki Vulcan 900, and the Honda Shadow 750 Aero. Four reviewers rated all four bikes and all four agreed that the Suzuki M50 was their choice as the best bike. Here is the link: 2006 Light-Middleweight Cruiser Comparison I ended up buying a 2007 M50 Limited Edition and have been extremely pleased with it. Good luck with your decision making. Attached Thumbnails

01-02-2008, 01:32 PM	#47 (permalink)
omegajim M-J Lifetime Achievement Award Join Date: Jan 2007 Bike: 1980 Yamaha XS850 Location: Washington County, WI Posts: 10,389	How close behind was the Kawasaki 900 Vulcan? I kind of like the looks of the Kawasaki, and besides the rest of the crowd can by the M50/C50 I remember once that I drove along with a guy who had a HD 883 and I was on the old Yamaha 850. Usually, from the stop sign, I would pull ahead and have to slow down to let him catch up. After we got to our destination the HD guy said "What are you driving so fast for, I had trouble keeping up." I replied "Fast, heck that was a bit over half throttle, you ain't seen fast yet." Although I've heard the HD Sportster 1200 is supposed to be pretty zippy. __________________ "FREE TIBET!"* With purchase of one Tibet of equal or greater value. "I have a driver's license. It doesn't mean I show up at the Indy 500 with my morgan." Ducky- NCIS and until very recently, we were Wisconsin Tourism Federation ----- no really.

01-02-2008, 02:45 PM	#48 (permalink)
Ext1jdh Top Gear ! Full Throttle! Join Date: Apr 2005 Bike: Sold Location: Elgin, IL, US Posts: 5,388	If you want to compare the Sportster 883 to any Suzuki cruiser, you have to compare it to the S50. Theres just no other way. __________________ I am lurking. I am likely to be eaten by a grue.

01-02-2008, 03:15 PM	#49 (permalink)
POE-BOY SAMICH U.B's LoveChild Join Date: Dec 2005 Bike: '07 Harley Road King Location: San Antonio, TX Posts: 1,212	Not a big fan of the 883. The only one I've ever ridden was a VERY rough ride. Granted I only rode it for about 10miles and I have no other experience with the 883 sportsters. The one I rode was the 883L (low). I do love the look of the nightster though. That's a sweet looking ride. Having owned a C50, if I was gonna get a bike and I could only choose between a C50 or a Sportster 883 (the 2 bikes mentioned in the original post) I would go with the C50 in a heartbeat. There really is no comparison IMO. DANG! This is an old thread though, no? __________________ http://www.lonestarmotorcyclealliance.com/

11-09-2007, 06:33 PM	#42 (permalink)
TFee3 Clunked into first gear Join Date: Jul 2007 Bike: '07 C90T Location: Gravois Mills MO Posts: 208	Hey clown (Rickster), read the post I just posted in your other putdown of my comments, and you'll know. Again, pull your head back in the sunshine!

01-01-2008, 09:47 PM	#45 (permalink)
m50cruiser Newbie Join Date: Jan 2008 Bike: 2008 C50 BOULEVARD BLACK Location: parkersburg,west virginia Posts: 10	I Agree With Hammersfan, Just Get An M50 And All Ur Troubles Will Disapear. Keep The Shiny Side Up M50 Cruiser

01-05-2008, 09:57 PM	#53 (permalink)
omegajim M-J Lifetime Achievement Award Join Date: Jan 2007 Bike: 1980 Yamaha XS850 Location: Washington County, WI Posts: 10,389	Lots go for the american icon thing. If i had money to throw away, i'd buy an icon too. Right after I win the lottery. __________________ "FREE TIBET!"* With purchase of one Tibet of equal or greater value. "I have a driver's license. It doesn't mean I show up at the Indy 500 with my morgan." Ducky- NCIS and until very recently, we were Wisconsin Tourism Federation ----- no really.

01-21-2008, 12:39 AM	#54 (permalink)
sgt_murf Newbie Join Date: Dec 2007 Bike: 2007 C50T & S40 Location: Ft Lauderdale FL Posts: 4	Not saying I have the answers as this one's personal choice. When I was younger the first road bike I learned to ride was a 59 pan, rode several sporty's 883, 900, 1200's, Road Kings, FL's FLH's. Today I have a C50T why? It's comfortable, handles well, do I miss the Harley's yes to a degree, which one is better -- depends on your view of better, pick what you like ride it and enjoy it. All bikes have their strong and weak points the only bikes I never like was the one's produced in the Soviet regime I thought they was crude. But I know some whom likes them, again indivdual choice. What's important is that you are in the wind and enjoying it.

01-24-2008, 12:09 PM	#55 (permalink)
dcstrng Ditch Magnet Join Date: Jun 2006 Bike: `96 FLHT Location: Colonial Beach, VA Posts: 183	<pick what you like ride it and enjoy it…> I think that is the correct answer… if raw performance was the issue, looking at anything cruiser-esque is silly… if availability of parts is an issue, looking at almost any bike except a big-twin HD is equally silly… if pure comfort is the answer, the touring bikes own the landscape… fact is, once one has ridden a few scoots over many years, I think one becomes far less parochial and just begins to enjoy the ride… except for those who envision a garage-queen, actually riding becomes proportionally more essential than just what one is straddling… __________________ Larry -- IBA

01-27-2008, 12:07 PM	#56 (permalink)
skynyrd fan Clunked into first gear Join Date: May 2005 Bike: 2005 Suzuki Boulevard C50 Posts: 208	After God , my wife and family, I love my C50. Looks like a no brainer from what Im reading here.

01-27-2008, 12:08 PM	#57 (permalink)
skynyrd fan Clunked into first gear Join Date: May 2005 Bike: 2005 Suzuki Boulevard C50 Posts: 208	Let us know how you make out.

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)